| 1st Team | ||
| Name | School | Year |
| **Khobi Kellerman | North Callaway | Senior |
| **Garik Hill | Elsberry | Senior |
| **Trey Miller | Van-Far | Senior |
| **Caden Wilburn | Van-Far | Senior |
| Gabe Cash | North Callaway | Junior |
| Carson Parker | Montgomery County | Junior |
| Preston Eckler | Mark Twain | Junior |
| Ben Burton | Wellsville | Senior |
| Kameron Worley | Bowling Green | Junior |
| George Niemeyer | Bowling Green | Junior |
| **Gabi Deters | Bowling Green | Senior |
| **Kaitlyn Kuntz | Clopton | Senior |
| **Tess Weakly | Elsberry | Senior |
| **Kenzie Ausfahl | North Callaway | Senior |
| **Mollie Stanek | Silex | Senior |
| **Jayle Jennings | Van-Far | Senior |
| Caitlin Bilhartz | Bowling Green | Senior |
| Jillian Lockard | Clopton | Senior |
| Anna Henke | Montgomery County | Senior |
| Calynn Lockard | Clopton | Senior |
| 2nd Team | ||
| Name | School | Year |
| Derek Richards | Louisiana | Senior |
| Derrick Taylor | Elsberry | Senior |
| Kaden Elliott | Mark Twain | Senior |
| Verlyn Johnson | Van-Far | Senior |
| David Liddell | Wright City | Senior |
| Dennis Hunt | Wellsville | Junior |
| Shawn Yates | Clopton | Junior |
| Zakk Eivins | Clopton | Sophomore |
| Kaleo Dade | Bowling Green | Senior |
| Dillion Seabaugh | Wright City | Junior |
| Madeline Norton | Bowling Green | Junior |
| Megan Hagemeier | Elsberry | Senior |
| Caitlyn Gloe | Louisiana | Sophomore |
| Emma Ross | Mark Twain | Sophomore |
| Mackenzie Ogle | Mark Twain | Junior |
| Hannah Prior | Montgomery County | Senior |
| Taylor Flake | Montgomery County | Sophomore |
| Dallyn Schmauch | North Callaway | Junior |
| Brooke Peckham | Wellsville | Senior |
| Jordan Garner | Van-Far | Senior |
| EMO Boys Champions | North Callaway | |
| Boys Coach of the Year | Matt Miller | |
| EMO Girls Champions | Clopton | |
| Girls Coach of the Year | Deaven Streed | |
| ** Denotes Unanimous Selections | ||