2012 Football EMO teams include Bowling Green, Clopton/Elsberry, Montgomery County, North Callaway, Van-Far with Community R-6, and Wright City.
** Denotes Unanimous Selections**
1ST TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Jack Hicks | Quarterback | Clopton/Elsberry | 11 |
| Nick Martin** | Running Back | Montgomery County | 12 |
| Malik McPike | Running Back | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Vance Allen** | Running Back | North Callaway | 12 |
| Charles Fraction | Wingback/Flanker | Clopton/Elsberry | 12 |
| Colt Ellis** | Offensive End | Montgomery County | 12 |
| Corey Brown** | Offensive End | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Rodney Bernat | Offensive Linemen | Montgomery County | 11 |
| Zac Eads** | Offensive Linemen | North Callaway | 12 |
| Mike Overstreet | Offensive Linemen | North Callaway | 11 |
| David Craighead | Offensive Linemen | North Callaway | 12 |
| Devin Linton | Offensive Linemen | Clopton/Elsberry | 11 |
1ST TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Jake Kent | Defensive End | Montgomery County | 11 |
| Justin Menard | Defensive End | North Callaway | 11 |
| Sam Kroll** | Defensive Linemen | Montgomery County | 12 |
| Davonte Kyles** | Defensive Linemen | North Callaway | 12 |
| Brandon Billings | Defensive Linemen | Van-Far | 12 |
| James Burleson | Linebacker | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Ryan Pezold** | Linebacker | North Callaway | 12 |
| Nick Hanff | Linebacker | Wright City | 12 |
| Nick Martin | Free Safety | Montgomery County | 12 |
| Ethan Gooch | Strong Safety | Van-Far | 12 |
| Corey Brown** | Corner | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Jacob Haubner | Corner | North Callaway | 12 |
| Ben Randolph | Place Kicker | Wright City | 11 |
| Will Vore | Punter | North Callaway | 12 |
2nd TEAM OFFENSE
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Ethan Gooch | Quarterback | Van-Far | 12 |
| Nick Hanff | Running Back | Wright City | 12 |
| James Burleson | Running Back | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Justin Menard | Running Back | North Callaway | 11 |
| Logan Boyd | Wingback/Flanker | Van-Far | 11 |
| Derico Blanks | Offensive End | Wright City | 12 |
| Delias Grimmett | Offensive End | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Clayton Schlanker | Offensive Linemen | Montgomery County | 11 |
| Sergio Ortega | Offensive Linemen | Wright City | 12 |
| Cameron Shinn | Offensive Linemen | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Ryan Pezold | Offensive Linemen | North Callaway | 12 |
| Brian Kurz | Offensive Linemen | Van-Far | 12 |
2nd TEAM DEFENSE
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Nick Stumbaugh | Defensive End | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Anthony Moses | Defensive End | North Callaway | 11 |
| Jordan Haden | Defensive Linemen | North Callaway | 12 |
| Todd Udelhoven | Defensive Linemen | Van-Far | 12 |
| Zach Garrett | Defensive Linemen | Clopton/Elsberry | 12 |
| Austin Killian | Linebacker | Montgomery County | 12 |
| Kyle Grajeda | Linebacker | North Callaway | 11 |
| Devin Linton | Linebacker | Clopton/Elsberry | 11 |
| Charles Fraction | Free Safety | Clopton/Elsberry | 12 |
| Colt Ellis | Strong Safety | Montgomery County | 12 |
| Evan Forrest | Corner | Montgomery County | 12 |
| Will Vore | Corner | North Callaway | 12 |
| Corey Brown | Place Kicker | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Corey Brown | Punter | Bowling Green | 11 |