Members of the 2019 Eastern Missouri Conference football team, selected by EMO Conference coaches, include…
First Team Offense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Shawn Yates | Quarterback | Clopton/Elsberry | 12 |
| Cody Cash* | Running Back | North Callaway | 11 |
| Devin Borghardt | Running Back | South Callaway | 12 |
| Mason Wortmann | Running Back | North Callaway | 12 |
| Bailey Sontag* | Wide Receiver | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Kyle Martin | Wide Receiver | Clopton/Elsberry | 12 |
| Carson Parker | Tight End | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Aaron Milner* | Offensive Line | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Ben Bondurant* | Offensive Line | North Callaway | 12 |
| Will Jeffries* | Offensive Line | North Callaway | 12 |
| Jacob Bowen | Offensive Line | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Ethan Everhart | Offensive Line | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Maximus Roed | Offensive Line | Van-Far | 12 |
| Will Janowski* | Wingback/Flanker | Wright City | 12 |
*Denotes unanimous selection
Second Team Offense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Ethan Abercrombie | Quarterback | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Gavin Deters | Running Back | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Avery Epperson | Running Back | Mark Twain | 12 |
| Branden Contreras | Running Back | Wright City | 11 |
| Deonta Fleming | Wide Receiver | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Jeremy Cundiff | Wide Receiver | Wright City | 12 |
| Garrett Schmidt | Tight End | Van-Far | 11 |
| Riley Walker | Offensive Line | Clopton/Elsberry | 11 |
| Jake Wolanski | Offensive Line | Clopton/Elsberry | 11 |
| Brandon Hill | Offensive Line | North Callaway | 11 |
| Tanner Vaughan | Offensive Line | South Callaway | 11 |
| Alex Polston | Offensive Line | Wright City | 11 |
| Mathias Bridges | Offensive Line | Mark Twain | 12 |
| Zakk Eivins | Wingback/Flanker | Clopton/Elsberry | 11 |
First Team Defense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Zakk Eivins* | Defensive End | Clopton/Elsberry | 11 |
| Kyle Yelton* | Defensive End | Mont Co | 11 |
| Mason Wortmann* | Defensive End | North Callaway | 12 |
| Braden Perez* | Defensive Linemen | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Will Jeffries* | Defensive Linemen | North Callaway | 12 |
| Maximus Roed* | Defensive Linemen | Van-Far | 12 |
| Avery Epperson* | Linebacker | Mark Twain | 12 |
| Shane Vehige* | Linebacker | Wright City | 12 |
| Clay Lazear | Linebacker | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Nick Mealy | Linebacker | South Callaway | 12 |
| Ben Miller* | Defensive Back | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Cody Cash* | Defensive Back | North Callaway | 11 |
| Devin Borghardt* | Defensive Back | South Callaway | 12 |
| Will Janowski* | Defensive Back | Wright City | 12 |
| J.J. McRoberts | Defensive Back | Wright City | 12 |
Second Team Defense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Matt McDannold | Defensive End | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Jace Barton | Defensive End | Mark Twain | 12 |
| John Hecktor | Defensive End | South Callaway | 11 |
| Tristen Murie | Defensive Linemen | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Christian Ebersohl | Defensive Linemen | Wright City | 12 |
| Jacob Bowen | Defensive Linemen | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Aaron Milner | Linebacker | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Blake Yelton | Linebacker | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Jasper Rees | Linebacker | South Callaway | 10 |
| Morgan Slatten | Linebacker | Van-Far | 12 |
| Landon Moss | Defensive Back | Mark Twain | 10 |
| Micheal Starks | Defensive Back | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Jadon Henry | Defensive Back | North Callaway | 12 |
| Marlando Parker | Defensive Back | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Maleek Mcpike | Defensive Back | Clopton/Elsberry | 12 |
First Team Speciality Positions
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Deonta Fleming* | Punter | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Will Janowski | Utility/Kick Returner | Wright City | 12 |
| Kyle Martin* | Place Kicker | Clopton/Elsberry | 12 |
| Verdell Johnson | Athlete (1st Team Only) | Van-Far | 12 |
| Don Boulware | COACH OF THE YEAR | North Callaway |
Second Team Speciality Positions
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Philli Marti | Punter | Mark Twain | 12 |
| Bryson Lay | Utility/Kick Returner | Van-Far | 10 |
| Caleb Pezold | Place Kicker | South Callaway | 9 |