Members of the 2019 Eastern Missouri Conference softball team, selected by EMO Conference coaches, include…
First Team
| *Brooklynn Fischer | Pitcher | Montgomery County | Sophomore |
| *Melissa Locke | Pitcher | Wright City | Senior |
| Tanner Turner | Pitcher | Bowling Green | Sophomore |
| *Grace Dameron | Catcher | Bowling Green | Junior |
| Tristen Head | Catcher | Wright City | Sophomore |
| Brooklyn Moore | Infield | Wright City | Senior |
| Mikayla Pennell | Infield | North Callaway | Junior |
| Lexi Plackemeier | Infield | Silex | Junior |
| Haylee Chandler | Infield | Bowling Green | Junior |
| *Kylie Jarmuszkiewcz | Outfield | Wright City | Sophomore |
| *Madeline Norton | Outfield | Bowling Green | Senior |
| Chloee Kinion | Outfield | Silex | Senior |
| *Jade Meier | Utility | Bowling Green | Junior |
| *Summer Boswell | Utility | Wright City | Senior |
| Clara Moser | Utility | North Callaway | Senior |
| Taylor Howard | Utility | Silex | Sophomore |
| Samantha Queathem | Utility | Montgomery County | Sophomore |
| Kylie Kinsler | Utility | Elsberry | Junior |
*Denote unanimous selection
Second Team
| Ellie Eckert | North Callaway | Senior |
| Makayla McAfee | Van-Far | Senior |
| Hayley Kimbley | North Callaway | Junior |
| Faith Rule | Louisiana | Senior |
| Devyn Keller | Van-Far | Sophomore |
| Ashley Queathem | Montgomery County | Senior |
| Tynesha Henderson | Elsberry | Junior |
| Carson Harlan | Silex | Sophomore |
| Summer Scherder | Bowling Green | Junior |
| Grace Deters | Bowling Green | Freshman |
| Brooklynn McKenney | Clopton | Junior |
| Tyra Henderson | Elsberry | Junior |