| **Denotes Unanimous Selection** | ||||||
| 1st Team | ||||||
| Position | Name | School | Year | |||
| Pitcher | Ben Bradley | North Callaway | Sr | |||
| Pitcher | Tristan Camp | Montgomery County | Jr | |||
| Pitcher | Ben Burton | Wellsville | Jr | |||
| Catcher | Hyrum Bishop | Montgomery County | Jr | |||
| Catcher | Cameron Huff | Wellsville | Jr | |||
| Infield | Blake Kendall | Clopton | Jr | |||
| Infield | Clark Zerr | North Callaway | Sr | |||
| Infield | Stephen Boedeker | Elsberry | Jr | |||
| Infield | Wyatt Gruenloh | Silex | Sr | |||
| Outfield | Kobe McPike** | Bowling Green | Sr | |||
| Outfield | Colin Parrish | Montgomery County | Jr | |||
| Outfield | Josh Hodde | Van-Far | Sr | |||
| Utility | Johnny Shaw ** | Montgomery County | Sr | |||
| Utility | Jordan Delashmutt | North Callaway | Jr | |||
| Utility | Blain Tuepker | Wright City | Soph | |||
| Utility | Ethan Burton | Wellsville | Jr | |||
| Utility | Dalton Strus | Clopton | Soph | |||
| Utility | Jake Adams | Silex | Sr | |||
| Coach of the Year: Kevin O’Neal – North Callaway | ||||||
| Conference Champions: North Callaway | ||||||
| 2nd Team | ||||
| Name | School | Year | ||
| Caden Wilburn | Van-Far | Jr | ||
| Tyler Bondurant | North Callaway | Sr | ||
| Parker Edmiston | Clopton | Sr | ||
| Chad Maupin | North Callaway | Sr | ||
| Evan Hartsock | Community R-6 | Jr | ||
| Tyler Bunch | Wellsville | Sr | ||
| Charles Turbyeville | Silex | Jr | ||
| Bryan Henke | Silex | Soph | ||
| Carson Parker | Montgomery County | Soph | ||
| Sam Althiser | North Callaway | Sr | ||
| Camron Swaringen | Wright City | Jr | ||
| Treyson Culwell | Van-Far | Sr | ||
| Isaac Ussery | Wellsville | Jr | ||