** Denotes Unanimous Selections
| 1st Team | |||
| **Kenzie Ausfahl | Pitcher | North Callaway | 11 |
| Sarah Harness | Pitcher | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Halle Mueller | Pitcher | Silex | 11 |
| **Gabi Deters | Catcher | Bowling Green | 11 |
| Tess Weakly | Catcher | Elsberry | 11 |
| **Jordan Garner | Infield | Van-Far | 11 |
| **Hanna Knipp | Infield | North Callaway | 12 |
| **Kaitlyn Kuntz | Infield | Clopton | 11 |
| Anah Noble | Infield | Bowling Green | 12 |
| **Lani Wilson | Outfield | North Callaway | 11 |
| Katy Horner | Outfield | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Makayla McAfee | Outfield | Van-Far | 10 |
| Katelynn Charlton | Utility | Bowling Green | 12 |
| Kallie Jo Lehenbauer | Utility | North Callaway | 12 |
| Maya Street | Utility | Clopton | 12 |
| Jayle Jennings | Utility | Van-Far | 11 |
| Anna Ford | Utility | Montgomery Co | 12 |
| Leah Vossen | Utility | Wright City | 12 |
2nd Team Mallory Feldewerth Bowling Green 12 McCaylee McPike Clopton 12 Abigail Jaspering Wright City 12 Megan Hagemeier Elsberry 11 Jordan Fischer Montgomery Co 12 Kaylyn McKee Bowling Green 12 Ellie Eckert North Callaway 10 Harper Thomsen North Callaway 11 Lexi Plackemeier Silex 9 Makaila Stuart Wellsville-Middletown 11 Natalie Thomas Community R-6 10 McKenzie Lathrom Mark Twain 12