1st Team Offense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Evan Milner | Quarterback | MC | SR |
| **Malik McPike** | Running Back | BG | SR |
| Justin Menard | Running Back | NC | SR |
| **Miguel Hudson** | Offensive End | NC | SR |
| ** Justin Hall** | Offensive End | MC | SR |
| **Jerad Jordan** | Wingback/Flanker | MC | SR |
| **Rodney Bernat** | Offensive Line | MC | SR |
| **Cameron Shinn** | Offensive Line | BG | SR |
| **Brett Metcalf** | Offensive Line | NC | SR |
| Clayton Schlanker | Offensive Line | MC | SR |
| Jake Kent | Offensive Line | MC | SR |
| Dylan Skeens | Utility/Kick Returner | MC | SR |
| Logan Boyd | Punter | VF | SR |
2nd Team Offense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Jake Niemeyer | Quarterback | BG | JR |
| Adam Holt | Running Back | BG | JR |
| Steven Soltysiak | Running Back | WC | SR |
| Conner Albrecht | Offensive End | VF | JR |
| Luke Longstreet | Offensive End | MC | SR |
| Ben Randolph | Wingback/Flanker | WC | SR |
| Logan Charlton | Offensive Line | BG | JR |
| Tyler Taylor | Offensive Line | NC | SR |
| Mike Pezold | Offensive Line | NC | JR |
| Jensen Elrod | Offensive Line | WC | SR |
| Christian Thompson | Offensive Line | WC | JR |
| Jack Hicks | Utility/Kick Returner | Clop | SR |
| Ben Randolph | Punter | WC | SR |
1st Team Defense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Justin Hall | Defensive End | MC | SR |
| Anthony Moses | Defensive End | NC | SR |
| Jake Kent | Defensive Linemen | MC | SR |
| **Tyler Taylor** | Defensive Linemen | NC | SR |
| Zach Kiel | Defensive Linemen | BG | JR |
| **Mike Pezold** | Linebacker | NC | JR |
| **Zeke Theissen** | Linebacker | MC | SR |
| Jackson Ringhausen | Linebacker | BG | JR |
| **Dylan Skeens** | Corner | MC | SR |
| Corey Brown | Corner | BG | SR |
| Kyle Kroll | Strong Safety | MC | JR |
| Steven Soltysiak | Free Safety | WC | SR |
| **Luke Longstreet** | Place Kicker | MC | SR
|
2nd Team Defense
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Tyler Talkington | Defensive End | BG | SR |
| Andrew Pfuhl | Defensive End | WC | SO |
| Aaron Henke | Defensive Linemen | MC | SR |
| Christian Thompson | Defensive Linemen | WC | JR |
| Brett Metcalf | Defensive Linemen | NC | SR |
| Tim Burks | Linebacker | WC | SR |
| Jackson Bishop | Linebacker | MC | SR |
| Rheed Leake | Linebacker | Clop | SR |
| Miguel Hudson | Corner | NC | SR |
| Ben Randolph | Corner | WC | SR |
| Malik McPike | Strong Safety | BG | SR |
| Jack Hicks | Free Safety | Clop | SR |
| Ben Randolph | Place Kicker | WC | SR |
** Denotes Unanimous Selections**